AP® Art History · Unit 10 · Topic 10.3
Appropriation: Quoting an Old Picture to Argue With It
Appropriation means borrowing a recognizable older artwork's exact composition and changing its materials or details to comment on history, power, or identity. The quote stays legible so the argument lands.
Appropriation works because the viewer already knows the original. An artist keeps the pose, the composition, even the title recognizable, then changes the one thing that carries ideology: the material, the body, the head. That gap between the familiar shape and the altered substance is where the argument happens. You cannot make the point without the quote, because the point is about how the original functioned and who it excluded.
Yinka Shonibare's Dancing at the Louvre and his Fragonard remakes keep every pose and the swing's arc from The Swing, a 1767 Rococo painting of aristocratic flirtation. He dresses the figures in Dutch wax print fabric, a batik-patterned cloth that looks African but was actually manufactured in Holland, copied from Indonesian batik, and sold successfully into West African markets rather than its intended one. He also removes the heads. The fabric's real colonial supply route does the same work as the headlessness: both strip away a stable, singular identity and expose aristocratic leisure, and cultural authenticity itself, as constructed and entangled in trade. Cindy Sherman works the same way with portraiture: she restages old master compositions with herself in prosthetics and makeup, photographed to match the lighting and framing of the source, exposing how portrait painting constructed idealized womanhood.
This sits next to the unit's other global contemporary strategies, mapped installations and wired video, because all three treat art history and geography as raw material to be rebuilt rather than inherited. Appropriation specifically targets a single canonical image and makes you see its original politics by disturbing it.
Key terms
- Appropriation
- Borrowing a recognizable existing artwork's composition or imagery and altering it to produce new meaning or critique.
- Dutch wax fabric
- Brightly patterned cloth industrially manufactured in Holland from Indonesian batik designs and sold mainly in West Africa.
- Tableau
- A life-size staged scene, often sculptural, that freezes figures in a composed arrangement like a painting.
- Rococo
- An eighteenth century European style marked by ornate decoration and scenes of aristocratic leisure and romance.
- Restaging
- Recreating an earlier artwork's pose, lighting, and framing with new figures or materials, as Cindy Sherman does with old master portraits.
Watch it explained
- How it worksHow does Shonibare keep Fragonard's exact composition while changing every material in it?
- Worked exampleShow me Dancing at the Louvre: the quilted border, the flattened gallery wall, the dancing figures.
- How it worksWalk me through Cindy Sherman restaging an old master portrait with prosthetics and a camera.
- Ties togetherHow does Dutch wax fabric's real route from Indonesia through Holland to West Africa complicate its meaning?
Check yourself
End of topic.