AP® English Literature and Composition · The Exam: Section I, Multiple-Choice
6.A-6.D Figurative Language and Comparison Questions
These questions never really ask you to name a device. They ask which property of the compared thing carries over into the passage, and what that transferred property does to meaning.
Think of a comparison as two images laid on top of each other, like transparent slides. Most of each slide stays dark. Only the traits the two images share light up and cross over into the poem or passage. 'The city breathed' overlays a city and a body. A body has organs, a face, breath, a pulse, a lifespan. The city has none of those literally. What lights up is rhythm: breathing is regular, involuntary, alive. That's the trait that carries. The question is testing whether you can name that trait and explain what it does, not whether you can say 'this is personification.'
The four devices show up as different signals in the wording, and spotting the signal is mechanical. A simile keeps the two things separate and joins them with like or as: 'chairs stood like soldiers.' A metaphor collapses them into flat identity: 'the chairs were soldiers.' Personification hands a human trait to something non-human without a comparing word at all: 'the chairs waited patiently.' Allusion reaches outside the text for a borrowed story or reference: 'the look of a Roman legion.' Once you see the signal, you know which bucket you're in, but naming the bucket is only step one.
The real test comes after identification: what does the lit-up trait do to the passage's meaning, and what did the writer leave dark on purpose. A debt compared to a tide might light up regularity and distant control while leaving out drowning entirely. That omission is a choice, and noticing it is what separates a surface answer from the one the question wants. This skill feeds directly into tone and theme questions elsewhere in the section, since the transferred trait usually is the tone.
Key terms
- Comparison
- Two images overlaid so that only their shared traits transfer into the passage's meaning.
- Simile
- A comparison that keeps both images separate and signals itself with like or as.
- Metaphor
- A comparison that states flat identity between two things without like or as.
- Personification
- Giving a human quality or action to something non-human, with no comparing word present.
- Allusion
- A reference that borrows meaning from a story, person, or event outside the text itself.
Watch it explained
- How it worksHow does a comparison draw as two images overlaid with only the shared trait lit up?
- How it worksWalk me through separating simile, metaphor, personification and allusion when a question names one.
- Worked exampleShow me the phrase the city breathed analyzed for what personification adds that plain description cannot.
- Common mistakeWhy isn't identifying a device the answer when a question asks what the comparison accomplishes?
Check yourself
End of topic.