JentooSAT®

SAT® · Reading and Writing: Information and Ideas

The Restatement Trap

The restatement trap is a wrong answer that just repeats a fact the text already gave. The correct ending always adds a new idea, usually a conclusion, mechanism, or contrast the text set up but hasn't said yet.

A restatement feels safe because it's definitely true. The text said it, so an answer that echoes it can't be wrong on the facts. That's exactly the trap: being true isn't the job. The blank is asking for the one sentence that finishes the passage's logic, and a text never spends its last sentence just repeating its first one. If a passage already told you sleep improves memory, an ending that says 'sleep helps memory' adds nothing. It's a fact box you've already drawn, redrawn.

The fix is mechanical: picture every sentence before the blank as a box, and ask what box is missing. If each sentence so far has added new information, the blank must add one more new box, not trace over an old one. Often that missing box is a conclusion that connects two given facts, a mechanism that explains why a result happens, or a contrast that names what separates two cases the text described but never directly compared. Scan the choices and cross out any that only reword a sentence you've already read.

This matters most on 'most logically completes the text' questions, where every choice is grammatically fine and factually consistent with the passage. The only thing separating four plausible sentences is whether one of them actually moves the argument forward. This skill sits right next to drawing inferences from evidence: both ask you to extend past what's stated, using the text's own logic rather than outside knowledge, to reach the one new box the passage is clearly building toward.

Key terms

Restatement trap
A wrong choice that accurately repeats information the text already gave instead of adding a new idea.
New box
A piece of information, like a conclusion, mechanism, or contrast, that the text has not yet stated.
Most logically completes the text
A question type asking which sentence best finishes a passage's reasoning, not just which sentence is true.
Mechanism
An explanation of why or how a stated effect happens, often the missing piece a completion question wants.

Watch it explained

  1. How it worksHow do you tell a restatement from a conclusion by asking which new box just got drawn?
  2. Common mistakeWhy isn't an accurate paraphrase ever the answer to a 'most logically completes the text' question?
  3. Worked exampleFind the restatement when a text has said sleep aids memory and one ending says sleep helps memory.

Check yourself

Your turneasy1 of 3
Text: In a trial with 103 volunteers, people who slept 8 hours after learning a list of word pairs recalled 40 percent more of the pairs next morning than people kept awake that night. The sleeping group did better still on the pairs they had rated as hard. Sleep, it appears, ______ Which choice most logically completes the text?

End of topic.