JentooBiology

AP® Biology · Unit 9

Investigation 1: Artificial Selection

Artificial selection breeds only the individuals with the most extreme trait value, so the next generation's mean shifts toward that extreme by an amount predicted by R = h times S.

Pick the tallest plants in a population and breed only them, and the offspring generation starts out taller on average than the parent generation did, because tall parents pass on the alleles that made them tall. This investigation uses Wisconsin Fast Plants and a trait called trichome number, the tiny hairs on the stem and leaves. You grow a parent generation, count trichomes on every plant, and plot the distribution: a bell-ish curve centered on some mean. Instead of breeding randomly, you take only the top sliver, say the highest 10 percent, and let those interbreed.

Draw both generations on the same trichome axis and you see the real story. The parent distribution has its peak somewhere in the middle. The selected breeders sit far out on the high tail. The offspring distribution is shifted: its peak sits closer to the breeders' mean than the original parent mean did, though usually not all the way there, because heritability is never a perfect 1. The breeder's equation captures this: R = h times S, where S is the selection differential, the gap between the selected breeders' mean and the whole parent population's mean, and h is heritability, the fraction of trait variation due to genes rather than environment. A bigger gap or higher heritability means a bigger generational shift.

This connects to natural selection and to Hardy-Weinberg ideas elsewhere in evolution: artificial selection is the same mechanism, just with a human choosing who breeds instead of the environment. It also sets up the misconception question about limits: selection cannot push a trait upward forever, because the process itself uses up the genetic variation it depends on.

Key terms

Selection differential (S)
The difference between the mean trait value of the selected breeders and the mean of the whole parent population.
Heritability (h)
The fraction of trait variation in a population that comes from genetic differences rather than environment.
Response to selection (R)
The actual shift in the offspring generation's mean trait value, predicted by R = h times S.
Trichome
A small hairlike outgrowth on a plant's stem or leaf surface, used as the measured trait in this investigation.
Fixed allele
An allele that has reached a frequency of 100 percent in a population, leaving no variation left to select on.

Watch it explained

  1. How it worksHow do you select on trichome number in Wisconsin Fast Plants over two generations?
  2. How it worksWalk me through the parent and offspring trait distributions drawn on the same axes.
  3. Worked exampleFind the change in mean trichome count when the top 10 percent of 200 plants are bred.
  4. Common mistakeWhy doesn't selecting hard for one trait keep working forever?

Check yourself

Your turn1 of 2
The response to selection follows the breeder's equation R = h times S, where S is the selection differential (the gap between the selected parents' mean trait value and the population mean) and h is the trait's heritability. If the selection differential is 3.63 and heritability is 0.619, find the expected shift R in the next generation's mean.

End of topic.