AP® Music Theory · Unit 2 · Topic 2.2

Notating Minor Key Signatures

A minor key's key signature always comes from its natural minor scale, never from the raised notes of harmonic or melodic minor. Any extra sharps or flats needed for those forms are written in as accidentals instead.

Every minor key has one key signature, and it belongs to the natural minor form. Natural minor uses no altered scale degrees beyond whatever sharps or flats sit in that key's signature, so its pattern of sharps or flats is fixed and stable. Harmonic minor raises the seventh degree, and melodic minor raises both the sixth and seventh going up, but those raised notes never get folded into the signature itself. Instead, a composer writes them in as accidentals, note by note, wherever the harmonic or melodic form is actually used.

This is why G minor, whose natural form has B flat and E flat, keeps only those two flats in its signature even in a passage built on harmonic minor. The raised seventh degree, F sharp, shows up as an accidental in front of the F each time it's needed, not as a standing sharp at the clef. The logic matters because a key signature is a promise about every occurrence of a pitch letter for the whole piece or section, and the raised degrees in harmonic and melodic minor are occasional, expressive choices, not permanent features of the key.

Minor key signatures connect directly to relative majors: every minor key shares its exact signature with the major key built on its relative, a minor third above. That shared signature is also why the circle of fifths works the same way for minor keys as for major ones, just centered on a different tonic. Once a signature is set from the natural form, everything else, harmonic minor's accidental, melodic minor's two accidentals, builds on top of it without changing it.

Key terms

natural minor
The minor scale form with no raised degrees, whose sharps or flats define the key signature.
harmonic minor
Natural minor with the seventh degree raised a half step, written with an accidental.
melodic minor
Natural minor with the sixth and seventh degrees raised going up, lowered again coming down.
relative major and minor
A major and minor key a minor third apart that share the same key signature.
accidental
A sharp, flat, or natural sign written before a note to alter it outside the key signature.

Watch it explained

  1. How it worksHow does a minor key signature come from the natural minor form and nothing else?
  2. Worked exampleFind the key signature for B minor and the accidental that harmonic minor adds on top of it.
  3. Worked exampleFind how many flats C minor, F minor, and B flat minor each carry.

Check yourself

Your turn1 of 2
A minor key signature is drawn from its natural minor form only, never adding accidentals for the raised degrees used in harmonic or melodic minor. If a minor key's relative major carries 4 flats, how many flats does that minor key's own signature carry?

End of topic.