AP® Microeconomics · Unit 6 · Topic 6.2
Negative Externalities
A negative externality happens when producing a good imposes costs on people who aren't part of the transaction, so the market produces more of it than is efficient. The fix is to make the producer pay the full social cost.
A factory upstream pays for labor, materials, and machines, but not for the dirty water it sends downstream. Those costs land on the town, not the firm, so the firm's marginal private cost (MPC) is lower than the true marginal social cost (MSC) of production. The firm keeps producing as long as its own costs are covered, ignoring the extra burden it dumps on everyone else. That gap between MPC and MSC, equal to the external cost per unit, is the whole story of a negative externality.
On the graph, the firm produces where MPC crosses demand, at quantity Q_private. The efficient quantity Q_social sits where MSC crosses demand instead, and it's always smaller. Between those two quantities, the social cost of each unit exceeds what buyers are willing to pay for it, so every unit from Q_social to Q_private destroys value. That lost value is the deadweight loss triangle, bounded by the demand curve on top and the MSC curve on the bottom.
A corrective tax set equal to the external cost per unit shifts MPC up until it matches MSC, so the firm's own bottom line finally reflects the harm it causes. Output falls to Q_social and the deadweight loss closes. This is the same triangle logic as monopoly deadweight loss: price not equal to marginal social cost, whether from market power or from an uncounted cost, means units are produced that destroy more value than they create, or in monopoly's case, units that would create value go unproduced.
Key terms
- Marginal private cost (MPC)
- The cost a producer actually pays to make one more unit.
- Marginal social cost (MSC)
- The true cost to society of one more unit, including costs borne by third parties.
- Externality
- A cost or benefit from a transaction that falls on someone not involved in it.
- Corrective tax
- A tax equal to the external cost per unit, used to make a producer face the full social cost.
- Deadweight loss
- The lost value from producing units where social cost exceeds what buyers value them at.
Watch it explained
- How it worksHow does marginal social cost sit above marginal private cost when a third party pays?
- How it worksShow me the overproduction and the deadweight loss on a negative externality graph.
- Worked exampleFind deadweight loss when MPC = 2 + Q, MSC = 6 + Q, and demand is P = 30 - Q.
- Common mistakeWhy isn't a tax on a polluting firm just a punishment with no efficiency purpose?
- Ties togetherHow does a negative externality open the same deadweight loss triangle a monopoly does?
Check yourself
End of topic.