AP® Statistics · Unit 1 · Topic 1.13

Completely Randomized, Blocked, and Matched Pairs Designs

A randomized block design groups similar subjects into blocks and randomizes treatment within each block; a matched pairs design is a special case where each subject (or pair) gets both treatments, acting as its own comparison.

A completely randomized design assigns all subjects to treatments by chance, with no grouping first. That works, but if subjects differ a lot on some trait that affects the outcome, like age affecting running speed, that variation can drown out the effect you're trying to measure. Blocking fixes this: you sort subjects into groups (blocks) that are similar on that trait, then randomize treatment separately within each block. The random assignment still happens, so you keep the cause-and-effect logic of an experiment, but now you've controlled a known source of variability instead of leaving it to chance.

A matched pairs design is blocking taken to its extreme: each block has only two observations, often the same subject measured twice, or two very similar subjects paired up. Because each subject is compared only to themselves (or their matched partner), any individual differences in baseline ability cancel out. Within each pair, which treatment comes first, or which side of the body gets which treatment, is still randomly assigned, so chance still decides the order or placement.

Both designs sit between full randomization and no randomization at all: you deliberately reduce noise by grouping on a variable you suspect matters, but you preserve randomness where it counts, within each group. The payoff shows up in the final analysis: less unexplained variability means a real treatment effect is easier to detect. This connects directly to later work on experimental design, where you'll judge whether a study's structure lets you draw a valid cause-and-effect conclusion.

Key terms

Block
A group of subjects that are similar on some variable expected to affect the outcome.
Randomized block design
An experiment where subjects are sorted into blocks first, then treatment is randomly assigned within each block.
Matched pairs design
A block design with blocks of size two, often the same subject under both treatments, used to cancel out individual differences.
Completely randomized design
An experiment where all subjects are randomly assigned to treatments with no prior grouping.

Watch it explained

  1. How it worksWalk me through a randomized block design for 60 runners split by age.
  2. How it worksHow does a matched pairs design use each person as their own comparison?
  3. Worked exampleShow me the design for testing two shoe soles by putting one on each foot of 30 runners.
  4. Going furtherWhat happens to the noise in your results when blocking removes a known difference?

Check yourself

Your turn1 of 2
A randomized block design splits runners into age blocks, then randomly assigns half of each block to treatment and half to control. If one block has 44 runners, find how many of those runners are assigned to the treatment within that block.

End of topic.